I love this! The fine tip allows me to get super smooth, fine lines on my lids while still allowing me to fill in my wing. In my opinion, it's much easier to use than the normal tip that is ultra sensitive to the angle of your hand. I've used STILA in the past and I've never had an issue with them drying out or running off my face, so their quality is much better than anything you'll get from a drug store. Although it stays on as long as needed, it also comes off easy without having to scrub your eyeballs off your face. Definitely a favorite!

Have been using this for years now. Love the smooth application. Does not smear and lasts throughout the day.

I bought this eyeliner for prime day, since I use it daily. It's the perfect black color, and dries quickly without any smudging (as long as you don't blink while it's drying.) The tip is medium sized so it's perfect for winged eyeliner, not too big, not too small. I wouldn't use it for very intricate or thin lines, but it's perfect for my everyday use. It's waterproof and won't come off if it gets wet, however, it might come off if you rub your eyes harshly. It comes off easily with any makeup remover, which is great. Overall, a great eyeliner and a great brand. I use it daily and would highly recommend for anyone in the market for a good black eyeliner.

This is my go to liquid eyeliner. I live in Florida & work a fairly physical job. After 8+ hours of sweating & running around, my eyeliner is still on point at the end of the day. The liner itself tends to get dry before I've used the entire tube but it's still worth the money! This eyeliner will “roll off” before it smears which I prefer. Doesn't feel to thick or heavy on the eyes.

first thing in the morning I love this eyeliner almost as much as my favorite brown mascara! This eyeliner is an absolute godsend. If anyone has tried to buy brown eyeliner from most stores, even the high-end ones, it never goes well. Whether you use Charlotte Tilbury, Sephora, Walmart, or Target, you know the struggles—they either don't have it, it's dry within the third day, used up too quickly, has too big of a tip for fine lines, or comes in a jar of liquid eyeliner. This one, however, goes on effortlessly. It stays on all day, it's easy to fix mistakes, and it lasts despite long days, rain, water—you name it. It lasts a long time and it's never dry. The best part? It doesn't make your pale skin look sickly. If you were on the fence, I urge you to go for it. This eyeliner is a total game-changer for anyone looking for a reliable brown liner that enhances your natural look without the typical hassles.

This is my go-to eyeliner. I've been using it for years and will never go back to another eyeliner. The color is dark, the lines are sharp and it goes on nice and smooth. It also lasts all day and doesn't smudge.

I have bought this eyeliner a dozen times but I think I got it from a different seller. Stila is amazing- goes on smooth and stays all day with no smudging. I have very itchy watery eyes and it is the only eyeliner that doesn't budge. But this one pen in particular i got this time felt used. The tip was dry and the ink was coming out patchy. Felt like a used eyeliner- like when I throw it away because it's empty. I could not send it back due to no refunds so I bought a new one. But that was weird. The new one had no issues and is back to being smooth and consistent.

This is my favorite eyeliner of all time at this price point. It doesn't flake off in little bits like Maybelline and Revlon's versions. The eyeliner, after practicing a bit, does a great wing. It has a nice dark pigment that works with most of my looks. And it doesn't sting when I put it on like another high-end brand. I can wipe my eyes without having it look like a raccoon. It also stays on all day - at least 12 hours. I use it EVERY SINGLE DAY and the tube lasts me for more than a month. Near the end of its life, however, the felt tip isn't as sharp and the ink isn't as strong - that's when you know you need to get the new one out. Lastly, the ink comes off easily with Micellar water. I subscribe and save this eyeliner so it's significantly cheaper than purchasing at Ulta.

This is by far the best liquid eyeliner pen on the market, I have been using it for years with zero complaints. It goes on smooth, lasts all day, and washes off easily at night. It doesn't smudge or run. I get compliments all the time on my wings.

Great line. Great colour. But only lasts a minute. Hardly anything in the tube.

Let me start by saying the fine tip is probably the best I've used in the last 20 years. However, that's where my excitement ends. The formula itself is not water proof and smudges easily. The photo is after about 4 hours of wear. Usually by lunch my liner needs a touch up.

Its excellent easy to use eyeliner that always stays put

Great color, unfortunately not staying on the eyes more then 1-2 hours.